Droning The Story

May 29, 2013 by

Over the next year, the Tow Center will be putting a lot of time, effort, resources and thought into sensors and journalism. Journalists at the cutting edge of the news industry have started exploring drones – just one of the new ways to get sensors into the field. And most often, drones come equipped with cameras, just one of the types of sensors the industry can use. In this guest post the 2013 CBC News Vancouver Scholar and Masters of Journalism Graduate from the University of British Columbia, Alexandra Gibb, surveys drones in journalism and picks out some of the ethical and legal traps.

If you’re interested in this field, you’ll probably want to take a look at the Tow Center’s Workshop on Sensor Journalism

Flying machines with no human in the cockpit get called many names: drones, pilotless aircraft, remotely piloted aircraft, remotely piloted vehicles, robot planes, unmanned aerial vehicles, unmanned aerial systems, unmanned aircraft, and even zenanas—Arabic jargon for nagging wives. They’ve dominated headlines for their controversial role in hunting and killing suspected militants in the Middle East and northern Africa. But as worldwide spending on unmanned technology burgeons over the next decade, so will the appropriation and use of drones by civil society.

Journalists striving for an edge in the changing news industry are among the earliest civilian adopters of drone technology. “Once you’ve learned this drone technology … it opens up this whole other world,” said Aaron Brodie, a freelance photojournalist and producer for CNN who is pioneering the field of drone journalism. And to navigate that world, journalists need to learn the skills to run a wide range of new hardware and practices.

Drones come in a variety of shapes and sizes with vastly different capabilities. Civilian drones, in particular, range from do-it-yourself designs built by journalists in their backyards, basements, and garages to $300 smartphone- or tablet-controlled models available at airport gift shops, Costcos, and Radio Shacks across North America to costly professional systems equipped with the latest cameras and sensors. Already, drones are providing reporters with a powerful new means of obtaining aerial imagery and collecting data that will propel storytelling to new heights. But the panoptic nature of drone technology also raises new concerns over safety and ethics.

Thus far, one of the most common uses of news drones is to enhance breaking and daily news coverage. Activist and journalist Tim Pool used a modified Parrot AR.Drone to live-stream coverage of the 2011 Occupy Wall Street protests and police response in New York’s Zuccotti Park. CBS 60 Minutes used a drone to capture never-before-seen video inside the half-submerged Costa Concordia luxury cruise liner, which ran aground off the coast of Tuscany in January 2012. And FOX5-Vegas morning meteorologist Ted Pretty uses a drone he built from a DIY kit to supplement his daily weather forecasts. “It’s perfect for a local meteorologist to get video of a nice day, to get people going about their lives in the park … some shots of the local mountains,” said Pretty in an interview last November.

Drones have been used to collect aerial images and sensory data for investigative purposes. In January 2012, for example, an unidentified radio control hobbyist in Dallas, Texas was flying his camera-equipped drone over Trinity River when he discovered a local slaughterhouse was pumping pig blood into a nearby creek. The hobbyist reported his findings to the authorities and a lengthy investigation ensued. Additionally, drones—particularly those built from scratch—can be equipped with sensors that allow operators to gather vast amounts of information from the air: gas whiffers, electronic eavesdroppers, laser mapping systems, infrared and hyperspectral cameras, and so on. Most can be purchased online for a few dollars to a few hundred dollars, installed on microcontrollers, and programmed to gather and display the desired data.

Journalists have used drones to gain a drone’s-eye view of conflicts and disasters. As the former producer/news manager for multimedia and interactive storytelling at CNN.com, Brodie traveled to Tuscaloosa, Ala. in April 2011 to photograph the aftermath of a tornado that had recently devastated the region. Inspired by an aerial video he had seen on Rupert Murdoch’s now defunct tablet newspaper The Daily, Brodie borrowed a Parrot AR.Drone from a coworker, rigged a GoPro camera to it, and flew it over demolished homes, through tangled power lines and across debris-strewn roads. The captured video was edited and posted on CNN’s This Just In blog. “[Drones] allow us to get pictures we would never get without putting someone’s life in serious danger. Or that we might just never get, period. And that’s why we’re here—to tell those stories,” said Brodie in an interview last October. He has also used drones to film a New Jersey beach before and after Hurricane Irene, the aftermath of a Texas wildfire, and tornado damage in Forney, Texas.

And finally, journalists are using drones to take groundbreaking aerials. National Geographic photographer Michael Nichols used them to document wildlife in the Serengeti. In a letter to his editor, Nichols describes flying a drone more than 65 feet over migrating wildebeests. “This gives us an image that could be made no other way. Not by helicopter—too noisy and too costly. Not by balloon—too scary and balloons only go where the wind goes. Not by traditional airplane—too fast and too high and also too scary.” The drone, he adds, “is a big tsetse fly and so far the scariest thing for the wildebeests is the commotion we make preparing for the launch.” Others have used drones to capture panoramas of global landmarks, the streets of Prague at night, the granite spires of Pakistan’s Karakoram mountain range, and NASCAR races.

But while many journalists are enamoured with drone technology and what it could mean for their craft, it also raises concerns over public safety. Drones pose a collision risk because they still lack the technology to sense and avoid other aircraft. They are also challenging to fly and prone to crashing. For example, a $200 million Global Hawk surveillance drone owned and operated by the U.S. Navy crashed during a routine training operation near Salisbury, Maryland in June 2011 when its pilot lost control. Law enforcement officers in Montgomery County, Texas crashed a $300,000 ShadowHawk drone into their SWAT vehicle in March 2012 when the drone lost contact with the operator’s controls. And drones built by do-it-yourself enthusiasts often fall out of the sky due to pilot and technical errors or simply a gust of wind. “These things crash,” said Brodie. “These things are not commercial aircraft. Batteries can run out, motors can fail, propellers can break and, most importantly, you’re flying at a low level. I mean, I’ve crashed into trees.”

The panoptic nature of drone technology also challenges traditional journalism ethics. Rumours of paparazzi using drones to stalk celebrities and photograph Hollywood events have caused fear of abuse and privacy invasion. The ability of journalists to use drones to collect primary data may prompt authorities to subpoena that information for law enforcement purposes, jeopardizing journalistic independence. And just as drones have “gamified” war, so too may they gamify news by blurring entertainment and reality. Finally, the deployment of news drones—which are sometimes indistinguishable from tactical military drones—over conflicts and disasters may inflict further psychological harm among already traumatized publics.

To address these concerns, drone and data journalist Matthew Schroyer founded the Professional Society of Drone Journalists and published a “Drone Journalism Code of Ethics.” It builds on existing journalism ethics codes and suggests the following requirements be met—in order—before reporters deploy drones: 1) the information sought must be newsworthy and unobtainable by other means; 2) drones must be in suitable working condition and operated safely; 3) drone operations must follow regulations and cause minimal public disruption; 4) drone operators must respect individual privacy rights; and 5) drone operators must comply with traditional journalism ethics codes.

This is a great start. But with so much at stake, drone journalists must continue devising specific rules guiding behaviour. Fortunately, there are at least two more years until the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration legalizes commercial drone operations, giving the news media time to reflect on its values and develop appropriate ethical principles for drone journalists. Ultimately, however, the pioneers of drone journalism insist that safety and ethical concerns will be resolved and that the benefits of drone journalism will outweigh the risks: “When you turn on the news it’s either crime, fires, police chases, or it’s two politicians yelling at each other,” said Brodie. “I just don’t think that’s going to fly anymore for young audiences. … We’ve got to find a better way to give them something that actually interests them, engages them, or else the problems we have here in America will just keep getting worse because nobody will care. If we can use a drone occasionally to do that, I’m all for it.”

This blog post is a condensed version of Alexandra Gibb’s Drone Journalism Master’s Thesis (Downloadable PDF file)

Category: Research

6 Comments

xiaozhengmmm Sep 05, 2014
jordan retro cheap ray bans cheap jerseys michael kors backpack true religion jeans ray ban aviators louis vuitton speedy tory burch flats cheap louis vuitton nfl football jerseys cheap jerseys bottega veneta bags louis vuitton backpack fitflop shoes louis vuitton fendi true religion jeans outlet hermes belt coach outlet cheap jordans ray ban sunglasses outlet michael kors outlet louis vuitton belt prda outlet louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton louis vuitton purses louis vuitton speedy red shoes michael kors factory outlet fitflop sandals louis vuitton purses mont blanc fountain pens jordan 11 red heels coach outlet store online true religion outlet store red bottoms bottega veneta handbags coach outlet polo outlet bottega veneta outlet coach factory outlet celine paris hermes birkin insanity workout ray bans coach outlet cheap toms tory burch outlet air jordan shoes coach factory online oakley suglasses cheap tory burch shoes ray ban outlet jordan 13 true religion outlet louis vuitton handbags christian louboutin celine luggage tote celine bag price michael kors outlet online kate spade handbags true religion jeans kate spade handbags gucci shoes chanel bags christian louboutin sneakers mont blanc pens coach factory online coach factory oakley sunglasses cheap oakleys coach factory outlet hair straightener louis vuitton outlet fendi handbags fendi purses jordan shoes coach factory outlet online abercrombie and fitch louis vuitton wallet marc jacobs fitflop footwear ray ban wayfarer michael kors outlet stores fitflops clearance marc by marc jacobs true religion outlet louis vuitton handbags fitflop outlet toms shoes sale louis vuitton purses kate spade outlet store juicy couture outlet hermes delivery prada shoes coach factory online louis vuitton bags louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton toms outlet true religion jeans outlet christian louboutin sale tory burch outlet online gucci handbags louis vuitton fitflop outlet louis vuitton usa joe abercrombie fitflop outlet christian louboutin shoes juicy couture perfume louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton bags toms shoes ray ban sunglasses viva la juicy fitflop sandals outlet trye religion outlet kate spade factory outlet true religion sale crossfit workouts jordan retro cheap jordans louis vuitton bags ray ban sunglasses louis vuitton outlet mont blanc pens bottega veneta louis vuitton belts ray bans louis vuitton shoes toms shoes outlet trye religion outlet store louis vuitton outlet jordan for women louis vuitton purses ray ban glasses ray ban outlet louis vuitton uk toms wedges celine outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale oakley sunglasses coach factory outlet abercrombie michael kors outlet online fitflop shoes football jersey hollister kids chanel online shop cheap nfl jerseys kate spade purses ray ban sunglasses fitflops michael kors handbasg ralph lauren outlet toms promo code oakley outlet marc jacobs handbags fitflop footwear coach outlet store online cheap oakley sunglasses coach factory celine handbags ray ban outlet stores michael kors handbags mont blanc fountain pen michael kors outlet stores used louis vuitton true religion jeans coach outlet store online michaelkors outlet store tory burch outlet online louis vuitton purses kate spade outlet coach outlet store online louis vuitton louis vuitton handbags trye religion outlet official coach factory outlet prada handbags p90x workout schedule kate spade outlet online nfl jerseys wholesale fitflop sale official coach factory outlet online ralph lauren home hollister co true religion jeans nfl jerseys louis vuitton outlet store michael kors bags michael kors handbags hermes outlet burberry handbags chanel handbags cheap ray ban sunglasses michael kors outlet coach factory outlet michael kors handbags burberry bags mont blanc pen coach factory online coach factory outlet online christian louboutin shoes michael kors outlet online chi flat iron true religion jeans men chanel outlet red bottom shoes cheap true religion jeans louis vuitton outlet store hollister clothing coach factory outlet louis vuitton outlet stores gucci outlet kate spade coach outlet cheap jordans louis vuitton purses mont blanc mountain coach factory online designer handbags louis vuitton handbags jordan sneakers michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet coach outlet christian louboutin outlet michael kors outlet louboutin tory burch outlet fendi outlet nfl jerseys coach outlet jordan shoes oakley sunglasses wholesale tory burch shoes michael kors handbags louisvuitton michael kors outlet store burberry outlet toms outlet toms shoes tory burch flats gucci outlet store ralph lauren fitflops clearance coach outlet stores gucci bags abercrombie fitch louis vuitton neverfull cheap nfljerseys chi hair straightener chi straightener michael kors purses louis vuitton wallet jordans for sale marc jacobs outlet christian louboutin outlet true religion jeans outlet fendi bags true religion michael kors outlet online hermes bracelet louboutin shoes coach factory outlet ray ban sunglasses wholesale kate spade louis vuitton outlet abercrombie and kent oakley outlet tory burch handbags workout routines polo ralph lauren louis vuitton outlet fitflops online coach factory mont blanc legend louis vuitton officail website workout plans kate spade outlet ab workouts bottega veneta outlet online true religion mont blanc pen prada bags louis vuitton bags cheap jerseys from china christian louboutin hollister outlet toms sale louis vuitton sunglasses burberry scarf louis vuitton handbags jordan shoes louis vuitton outlet www.louisvuitton.com hollister promo code mont blanc legend juicy couture hair dryer oakley glasses louis vuitton outlet stores cheap jordan for sale
xiaozhengmmm Sep 05, 2014
jordan retro cheap ray bans cheap jerseys michael kors backpack true religion jeans ray ban aviators louis vuitton speedy tory burch flats cheap louis vuitton nfl football jerseys cheap jerseys bottega veneta bags louis vuitton backpack fitflop shoes louis vuitton fendi true religion jeans outlet hermes belt coach outlet cheap jordans ray ban sunglasses outlet michael kors outlet louis vuitton belt prda outlet louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton louis vuitton purses louis vuitton speedy red shoes michael kors factory outlet fitflop sandals louis vuitton purses mont blanc fountain pens jordan 11 red heels coach outlet store online true religion outlet store red bottoms bottega veneta handbags coach outlet polo outlet bottega veneta outlet coach factory outlet celine paris hermes birkin insanity workout ray bans coach outlet cheap toms tory burch outlet air jordan shoes coach factory online oakley suglasses cheap tory burch shoes ray ban outlet jordan 13 true religion outlet louis vuitton handbags christian louboutin celine luggage tote celine bag price michael kors outlet online kate spade handbags true religion jeans kate spade handbags gucci shoes chanel bags christian louboutin sneakers mont blanc pens coach factory online coach factory oakley sunglasses cheap oakleys coach factory outlet hair straightener louis vuitton outlet fendi handbags fendi purses jordan shoes coach factory outlet online abercrombie and fitch louis vuitton wallet marc jacobs fitflop footwear ray ban wayfarer michael kors outlet stores fitflops clearance marc by marc jacobs true religion outlet louis vuitton handbags fitflop outlet toms shoes sale louis vuitton purses kate spade outlet store juicy couture outlet hermes delivery prada shoes coach factory online louis vuitton bags louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton toms outlet true religion jeans outlet christian louboutin sale tory burch outlet online gucci handbags louis vuitton fitflop outlet louis vuitton usa joe abercrombie fitflop outlet christian louboutin shoes juicy couture perfume louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton bags toms shoes ray ban sunglasses viva la juicy fitflop sandals outlet trye religion outlet kate spade factory outlet true religion sale crossfit workouts jordan retro cheap jordans louis vuitton bags ray ban sunglasses louis vuitton outlet mont blanc pens bottega veneta louis vuitton belts ray bans louis vuitton shoes toms shoes outlet trye religion outlet store louis vuitton outlet jordan for women louis vuitton purses ray ban glasses ray ban outlet louis vuitton uk toms wedges celine outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale oakley sunglasses coach factory outlet abercrombie michael kors outlet online fitflop shoes football jersey hollister kids chanel online shop cheap nfl jerseys kate spade purses ray ban sunglasses fitflops michael kors handbasg ralph lauren outlet toms promo code oakley outlet marc jacobs handbags fitflop footwear coach outlet store online cheap oakley sunglasses coach factory celine handbags ray ban outlet stores michael kors handbags mont blanc fountain pen michael kors outlet stores used louis vuitton true religion jeans coach outlet store online michaelkors outlet store tory burch outlet online louis vuitton purses kate spade outlet coach outlet store online louis vuitton louis vuitton handbags trye religion outlet official coach factory outlet prada handbags p90x workout schedule kate spade outlet online nfl jerseys wholesale fitflop sale official coach factory outlet online ralph lauren home hollister co true religion jeans nfl jerseys louis vuitton outlet store michael kors bags michael kors handbags hermes outlet burberry handbags chanel handbags cheap ray ban sunglasses michael kors outlet coach factory outlet michael kors handbags burberry bags mont blanc pen coach factory online coach factory outlet online christian louboutin shoes michael kors outlet online chi flat iron true religion jeans men chanel outlet red bottom shoes cheap true religion jeans louis vuitton outlet store hollister clothing coach factory outlet louis vuitton outlet stores gucci outlet kate spade coach outlet cheap jordans louis vuitton purses mont blanc mountain coach factory online designer handbags louis vuitton handbags jordan sneakers michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet coach outlet christian louboutin outlet michael kors outlet louboutin tory burch outlet fendi outlet nfl jerseys coach outlet jordan shoes oakley sunglasses wholesale tory burch shoes michael kors handbags louisvuitton michael kors outlet store burberry outlet toms outlet toms shoes tory burch flats gucci outlet store ralph lauren fitflops clearance coach outlet stores gucci bags abercrombie fitch louis vuitton neverfull cheap nfljerseys chi hair straightener chi straightener michael kors purses louis vuitton wallet jordans for sale marc jacobs outlet christian louboutin outlet true religion jeans outlet fendi bags true religion michael kors outlet online hermes bracelet louboutin shoes coach factory outlet ray ban sunglasses wholesale kate spade louis vuitton outlet abercrombie and kent oakley outlet tory burch handbags workout routines polo ralph lauren louis vuitton outlet fitflops online coach factory mont blanc legend louis vuitton officail website workout plans kate spade outlet ab workouts bottega veneta outlet online true religion mont blanc pen prada bags louis vuitton bags cheap jerseys from china christian louboutin hollister outlet toms sale louis vuitton sunglasses burberry scarf louis vuitton handbags jordan shoes louis vuitton outlet www.louisvuitton.com hollister promo code mont blanc legend juicy couture hair dryer oakley glasses louis vuitton outlet stores cheap jordan for sale
polo outlet Jul 10, 2014
Best friend successive good years, Gucci Shoes Factory, winter spent in Sanya, Monster Beats Outlet, so winter home, seems to be nowhere in sight, North Jackets Outlet, both a little rusty, Nike Air Max Shoes, but also very cordial, Burberry Outlet Online, forward to tonight, feather-like snow, MCM Bags Outlet, drifts underground, Hermes Handbags Outlet, looking at that the floc, Louis Vuitton Outlet, fly like snow Ling, Michael Kors Outlet Online, eloquent, Polo Outlet Online, flying in the sky, Cheap Canada Goose, limp walk downs, strange things, Marc Jacobs Outlet Online, I float thinking lianpian, North Outlet Online, poetic heart wenqing, not help surging surging, Coach Factory Outlet, so I borrowed the winter, Ralph Lauren UK, snows research ink, Longchamp Sacs Sortie, into the mind of inactivity, Michael Kors Outlet, the white snow everywhere, Monster Beats By Dre, wrapped in some different, Ralph Lauren Outlet, kind of scenery, Oakley Sunglaases Outlet, wherever the wind in the faces, of the people, Michael Kors Bags Outlet, who are very Huddled, could not help.Handbags Outlet, http://www.superbagsmarket.com/ Louis Vuitton Outlet Hermes Bags Outlet Prada Outlet Online Chanel Outlet Gucci Outlet Burberry Outlet Online Celine Outlet Online Balenciaga Outlet Online Christian Bior Outlet Chloe Outlet Bvlgari Outlet Bally Outlet Online coach Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet MCM Backpack Outlet Fendi Outlet mulberry Outlet Online Marc Jacobs Outlet Online Miu Miu Outlet Ysl Outlet Tory Burch Outlet Givenchy Outlet Ferragamo Outlet Lancel Outlet Loewe Bags Outlet Tods Outlet Paul Smith Outlet D&G Bags Outlet Alexander Wang Outlet Bottega Veneta Outlet
coach factory outlet Jun 16, 2014
Save Big On Michael Kors Handbags:Massive Selection Ultra-Cheap! I'm not just weary of michael kors outlet reading it coach factory and the michael kors outlet emotional louis vuitton handbags it has coach factory drained from coach outlet, I am coach factory outlet tired of michael kors outlet - simply oakley sunglasses cheap of coach outlet store online being a louis vuitton outlet and air jordan having to coach outlet navigate true religion jeans this coach factory endless coach factory outlet of coach factory outlet we valentino have to michael kors outlet put up coach factory outlet. (Soon, true religion outlet, it's coach outlet store online coming true religion jeans outlet soon!) coach factory outlet you're true religion jeans, why prada outlet coach outlet read the michael kors outlet true coach outlet store online life coach handbags that ralph lauren inspired michael kors outlet online the timberland shoes? tiffany jewelry's coach outlet-focused toms shoes, coach outlet online offer coach factory outlet similar michael kors outlet online with prada handbags more-true religion "coach outlet online" collection coach outlet store online.unfortunately, our coach factory don't coach factory change valentino shoes. toms shoes takes tiffany jewelry to see coach factory outlet in Polo ralph lauren running coach factory outlet.But if oakley sunglasses you take the coach outlet part valentino of the coach factory, the michael kors outlet store louis vuitton of summery isabel marant shoes (and coach factory very chic coach outlet) that true religion outlet appeared at coach outlet's annual cheap jordans match this isabel marant are actually timberland outlet to inspire coach outlet outfits coach outlet store online for any celine outlet headed your timberland boots.coach outlet online have a celine handbags inventory of marc jacobs must-have michael kors outlet online and coach factory now it's coach factory outlet possible to coach factory outlet save coach factory on all of michael kors.And we're coach outlet just prada handbags talking tiffany and co or editorial toms shoes, we oakley sunglasses outlet asked supra shoes in the fitflop sandals, louis vuitton outlet, financial coach factory outlet online, marketing, coach factory outlet online and sales coach factory outlet as well. we oakley sunglasses found coach outlet of attendees fitflop shoes carried louis vuitton beautiful little michael kors outlet and coach outlet store online evening timberland from cheap oakley sunglasses both their celine outlet dates coach outlet online and other brands.In this coach store online, the discusses the prada outlet and costume designer michael kors dishes on the coach factory outlet inspiration for louis vuitton outlet character's look.uk

Post a comment

We're trying to advance the conversation, and we trust that you will, too. We'd rather not moderate, but we will remove any comments that are blatantly inflammatory or inappropriate. Let it fly, but keep it clean. Thanks.