Tow Center Launches Amateur Footage: A Global Study of User-Generated Content in TV and Online News Output

Crediting is rare, there’s a huge gulf in how senior managers and newsdesks talk about it and there’s a significant reliance on news agencies for discovery and verification. These are some of the key takeaways of Amateur Footage: A Global Study of User-Generated Content in TV and Online News Output published today by the Tow Center of Digital Journalism.

 

The aim of this research project was to provide the first comprehensive report about the use of user-generated content (UGC) among broadcast news channels. UGC being – for this report – photographs and videos captured by people unrelated to the newsroom, who would not describe themselves as professional journalists.

 

Some of the Principle Findings are:

  • UGC is used by news organizations daily and can produce stories that otherwise would not, or could not, be told. However, it is often used only when other imagery is not available. 40% of UGC on television was related to Syria.
  • There is a significant reliance on news agencies in terms of discovering and verifying UGC. The news agencies have different practices and standards in terms of how they work with UGC.
  • News organizations are poor at acknowledging when they are using UGC and worse at crediting the individuals responsible for capturing it. Our data showed that: 72 percent of UGC was not labeled or described as UGC and just 16 percent of UGC on TV had an onscreen credit.
  • News managers are often unaware of the complexities involved in the everyday work of discovering, verifying, and clearing rights for UGC. Consequently, staff in many newsrooms do not receive the training and support required to develop these skills.
  • Vicarious trauma is a real issue for journalists working with UGC every day – and it’s different from traditional newsroom trauma. Some newsrooms are aware of this – but many have no structured approach or policy in place to deal with it.
  • There is a fear amongst rights managers in newsrooms that a legal case could seriously impact the use of UGC by news organisations in the future

 

This research was designed to answer two key questions.  First, when and how is UGC used by broadcast news organizations, on air as well as online?  Second, does the integration of UGC into output cause any particular issues for news organizations? What are those issues and how do newsrooms handle them?

 

The work was completed in two phases. The first involved an in-depth, quantitative content analysis examining when and how eight international news broadcasters use UGC.  1,164 hours of TV output and 2,254 Web pages were analyzed here. The second was entirely qualitative and saw the team interview 64 news managers, editors, and journalists from 38 news organizations based in 24 countries across five continents. This report takes both phases to provide a detailed overview of the key findings.

 

The research provides the first concrete figures we have about the level of reliance on UGC by international news channels. It also explores six key issues that newsrooms face in terms of UGC. The report is designed around those six issues, meaning you can dip into any one particular issue:

1) Workflow – how is UGC discovered and verified? Do newsrooms do this themselves, and if so, which desk is responsible? Or is UGC ‘outsourced’ to news agencies?

2) Verification – are there systematic processes for verifying UGC? Is there a threshold that has to be reached before a piece of content can be used?

3) Permissions – how do newsrooms seek permissions? Do newsrooms understand the copyright implications around UGC?

4) Crediting – do newsrooms credit UGC?

5) Labeling – are newsrooms transparent about the types of UGC that they use in terms of who uploaded the UGC and whether they have a specific agenda?

6) Ethics and Responsibilities – how do newsrooms consider their responsibilities to uploaders, the audience and their own staff?

 

The full report can be viewed here.

Category: Past Events

4 Comments

coach factory outlet Jul 27, 2014
coach factory outlet hollister clothing store kate spade outlet michael kors outlet sac portefeuille louis vuitton outlet coach outlet oakley sunglasses outlet kate spade outlet online louis vuitton handbags coach factory outlet ray ban sunglasses coach outlet store online michael kors outlet online coach outlet prada outlet cheap ray ban sunglasses air jordans true religion jeans coach outlet coach factory outlet louis vuitton outlet coach factory outlet oakley sunglasses michael kors outlet online tory burch outlet fitflop uk michael kors coach factory outlet prada handbags coach bags outlet louis vuitton handbags cheap oakley sunglasses air jordans shoes true religion jeans outlet louis vuitton coach outlet store online michael kors handbags coach factory outlet online coach factory online michael kors outlet coachfactory.com coach factory outlet prada handbags abercrombie & fitch fitflops michael kors outlet online coach outlet ray-ban sunglasses coach factory outlet online abercrombie and fitch valentino louis vuitton outlet coach outlet online fitflop uk coach factory outlet online isabel marant Shoes timberland boots tiffany and co jewelry oakley sunglasses coach outlet online true religion outlet coach outlet coach outlet store online kate spade outlet online coach factory coach factory outlet timberland shoes true religion outlet kate spade outlet coach outlet store online coach outlet coach factory outlet online true religion coach outlet store online true religion jeans coach factory abercrombie & fitch michael kors outlet online tory burch shoes official coach factory outlet louis vuitton coach factory outlet hollister clothing michael kors outlet polo ralph lauren coach outlet store online tiffany and co coach factory outlet tory burch michael kors outlet coach outlet online michael kors outlet online coach outlet online coach outlet store online coach factory outlet online celine outlet coach outlet online celine handbags marc jacobs outlet michael kors outlet store coach outlet coach outlet store online fitflops ray-ban sunglasses ralph lauren coach factory outlet toms shoes coach outlet online supra shoes coach outlet fitflop outlet tiffany jewelry tory burch outlet online tiffany and co abercrombie and fitch official coach online factory sale michael kors outlet michael kors outlet online coach outlet marc jacobs coach factory outlet kate spade online cheap oakley sunglasses celine bags coach factory outlet coach handbags timberland boots fitflops coach factory outlet michael kors outlet coach factory outlet louis vuitton handbags kate spade oakley sunglasses cheap coach handbags outlet coach outlet online michael kors factory outlet michael kors outlet
human wigs Jul 24, 2014
Purchasing a lacewig cap protectant sealer will easily prolong the life of your lace human hair wigs. What the protectant is sealing are the hairs knotted on the lace. Overtime, these wigs for women can shed from regular washing or brushing. The product also helps to strengthen the lace front for adhesives to adhere to easily. This is also perhaps one of the easiest ways to maintain your lacewig. After purchasing, simply brush your lacewig hair, spray on the sealer and let dry. It is suggested that you reapply about 2-3 times if it is a brand new lace long wigs. Overtime, you should also reapply before washing or getting it professionally repaired.
aapas ki baat Jul 20, 2014
Hello. How are you? It is so lovely. Like your website because its style so nice. The online TV is very great aapas ki baat Feature. We can get information about current affairs through online TV website at any time and every where I will suggest my friends to visits this site.
polo outlet Jul 10, 2014
Walking on the way home, Nike Air Jordan, suddenly a scenery touched, Ralph Outlet, stopped to savor, MCM Outlet Online, to put a camera gesture, Polo Outlet Online, to leave a shallow spring, Gucci Shoes UK, of negatives here, Michael Kors Outlet, deep in her heart extended spring scenery, Marc Jacobs Bags Outlet, etc, returned home, Canada Goose Jackets, using bamboo memo box, Ralph Lauren Outlet, to do with pen, Michael Kors USA, and ink painting, North Jackets Outlet Online, the intention to write, a sweet words, Beats By Dre, do a recall album, wait until old age, Hermes Bags Outlet, come to appreciate slowly, North Clearace Outlet Online, walked with light, Burberry Bags Outlet, footsteps walked on, the King, Monster Headphones Outlet, or the original scene, Longchamp Pairs, people are still the original person, Prada Outlet Online, just change a mood, Michael Kors Outlet Online, all plain people, Cheap Oakley Sunglaases, things, Coach Factory Shop, and it was better together. Handbags Outlet Online, http://www.superbagsmarket.com/ Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Hermes Bags Outlet Online Prada Outlet Chanel Outlet Online Gucci Outlet Online Burberry Outlet Celine Outlet Balenciaga Outlet Christian Bior Outlet Online Chloe Outlet Online Bvlgari Outlet Online Bally Outlet coach Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online MCM Backpack Outlet Online Fendi Outlet Online mulberry Outlet Marc Jacobs Outlet Miu Miu Outlet Online Ysl Outlet Online Tory Burch Outlet Online Givenchy Outlet Online Ferragamo Outlet Online Lancel Outlet Online Loewe Bags Outlet Online Tods Outlet Online Paul Smith Outlet Online D&G Bags Outlet Online Alexander Wang Outlet Online Bottega Veneta Outlet Online

Post a comment

We're trying to advance the conversation, and we trust that you will, too. We'd rather not moderate, but we will remove any comments that are blatantly inflammatory or inappropriate. Let it fly, but keep it clean. Thanks.