On the Ethics of Data-Driven Journalism: of fact, friction and public records in a more transparent age

November 14, 2013 by

While ethics in journalism have been defined and upheld for decades, the context they’re practiced within has shifted with changes in technology and society. That’s true of public records as they become increasingly digitized and more liquid, flowing from file cabinets and county servers onto the World Wide Web. Security and privacy by obscurity are no longer enough to protect sensitive data, particularly as the traditional gatekeeper to such stores disappear and publication has become dramatically democratized around the world. In 2013, we’re just starting to really grapple with the issues that are presented here, despite years of data breaches in the public and private sector, and warning from researchers about poor information minimization or redaction, lax security protocols or lapses in common sense.

As digital government comes to more towns and the capacity to do data-driven journalism becomes integrated into more newsrooms, these tensions and their consequences are only going to grow more difficult. If data journalists and their editors don’t apply the same ethical lens to the data they publish that has governed protecting sources, they will run the risk of violating the trust of the public they seek to inform.

Given the increased reach and velocity of digital media, data journalists must be more conscious of ethics than ever. Experienced or rookie journalists need to know how to turn data into journalism in a way that both protects and informs the public the data describes.

If you’re applying a data-driven lens, as Jeff Sonderman highlighted at the Poynter Institute, you’ll need to ask a series of basic questions.

“In every situation you face, there will be unique considerations about whether and how to publish a set of data,” he wrote. “Don’t assume data is inherently accurate, fair and objective. Don’t mistake your access to data or your right to publish it as a legitimate rationale for doing so. Think critically about the public good and potential harm, the context surrounding the data and its relevance to your other reporting. Then decide whether your data publishing is journalism.”

If we want to get a handle of the future that’s coming quickly to cities and countries around the world, it’s useful to look at the hotspots where conflict has already burned a hole in public imagination after that arrival. Three recent stories are useful to consider the tangle of ethical issues presented by different entities publishing public records:

  1. The “gun map,” in upstate New York
  2. The use of mug shots by for-profit services
  3. The NSA papers published by The Guardian and The Washington Post

Aiming to make a data-driven statement and missing the target

In December 2013, a newspaper provoked a national conversation about the use of public records by when the Westchester Journal News, published a story about gun owners and (much more controversially) a map that listed the names and home addresses of every pistol permit-holder in New York State’s Westchester and Rockland counties. The Journal News had gained the permit data from a Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) request and then geocoded it.

The outrage that resulted was instructive: this data was public and subject to a freedom of information law. As Reuters media columnist Jack Shafer argued, public records are public, so anyone can do what they want with them. Ceding that the ability to do so exists, did that make it ethically sound to publish the names and addresses of permit holders?

Then and now, I’d say no: they added nothing to the story and put some people unnecessarily at risk. Al Tompkins, a senior faculty member at the Poynter Institute, agreed:

“Journalists broadcast and publish criminal records, drunk driving records, arrest records, professional licenses, inspection records and all sorts of private information,”he wrote, “but when we publish private information we should weigh the public’s right to know against the potential harm publishing could cause.”

The question of what to do about guns, maps and disturbing data in New York was answered in part by the state legislature and senate, when it passed legislation that created an anonymity exemption for gun permit holders. The issues this situation raised, however, will be central to data journalism in every state and country around the world. As more government records become digital, how they are used and the context that the data is given will only become more important.

The conflict over guns and data demonstrated how government data could be published by a media organization in a way that not only made citizens quite uncomfortable but put some at risk by making them more easily discoverable.

It also highlighted an issue with data quality and journalism: more than tthree quarters of the data in the gunmap was inaccurate. The Journal News took the map offline in January 2013.

Given that such mistakes will also inevitably become part of the journalism landscape, media organizations will have to grapple with the question of what to do about correcting them. “We regret the error” has long been a fixture in fact-based journalism. Soon, as New York Times interactive developer Jacob Harris explored for Mozilla’s “Source”, more readers should expect to see programming corrections when acts of data-driven journalism go awry. Harris argues convincingly that every media entity that’s working with gathering, analyzing or publishing data will need to have and use a correction policy when there are errors in code, computation or collection.

Getting mugged by data online

In an ideal world, acts of journalism shine a light on a dodgy practices that galvanizes action from the people who have power to change them. This past February, Jonathan Hochman published an op-ed at SearchEngineLand urging Google to crack down on the mugshot extortion racket, highlighting shady websites that scrape or download public records from government and publish pictures of booking photographs online. These sites then offer to remove the pictures for a fee. Until recently, those pictures were showing up in Google search for names, significantly amplifying and codifying the impact of arrests.

While some issues are systemic and resistant to simple policy tweaks, from poverty to pollution to education to crime, others are more susceptible to shifts from powerful new gatekeepers to information.This is such an instance. In October 2013, in response to this Hochman’s op-ed, Google changed its search algorithm to push these mugshot sites down in results. (That shift was also reported by the New York Times in a feature on online mug shots that made a much broader swath of the public aware of the ongoing “extortion-by-public-record” digital racket.) Credit card companies are also considering cutting off electronic payment services to these sites. That choice, along with Google’s shift, has caused some alarm among observers like GigaOm senior writer Mathew Ingram, who is concerned about the long-term implications of these shifts, and Tow Center director Emily Bell:

 

There are some truly thorny issues here for data editors to consider. On the one hand, these are public records that may hold significant value for the public interest. As Ingram notes, organizations like the Reporters’ Committee for the Freedom of the Press don’t want to see media access to such information reduced because of misuse, as occurred with gun registry data in New York. On the other hand, the potential for these records to negatively affect the lives of people without the power or resources or influence to escape the consequences of their digital amplification is significant, given the nearly ubiquitous behavior of potential employers or academic institutions to search for applicants online.

What mugshots mean for public data is, in other words, a fine conundrum for the digital age. Data scientist Hillary Mason suggests moving beyond the frame of outright removal or unfettered online access.

“The debate around fixing this problem has focused on whether the data should be removed from the public entirely,” she wrote. “I’d like to see this conversation reframed around how we maintain the friction and cost to access technically public data such that it is no longer economically feasible to run these sorts of aggregated extortion sites while still maintaining the ability of journalists and concerned citizens to explore the records as necessary for their work.”

Given that potential misuse or distortion of government data by media and the public has often been cited by government officials and civil servants as a reason not to release it, data journalists, open government advocates and “civic hackers” do hold some responsibility to protect the privacy and security of the public described in the data. While embarrassment of public officials behaving badly is a terrible rationale for not publishing data, considering the impact upon the lives or professional prospects of private citizens should at least give journalists pause. Many kinds of data have been obscured by being bound up on paper, in file cabinets. Once it becomes liquid, with the friction of physically visiting a reading room or file cabinet in a courtroom basement removed, the context for its collection can collapse rapidly.

On Wikileaks, Snowden and the role of intermediaries

Nowhere has the issue of “potential harm” been more contentious than when Wikileaks released data from the U.S. Department of Defense and Department of State to multiple news organizations in 2010 and 2011. Every media organization that reviewed classified cables or logs from the Pentagon had to decide not only whether to publish them but how, balancing redacting the names of people who might be put at risk with the public’s right to know what was done on their behalf by government. The technical capacity to move through millions of lines of messy data in proprietary formats, however, only rests with a limited number of news organizations. If the capacity to do data-driven journalism at scale isn’t democratized, this dynamic could enshrine traditional media power structures.

In 2013, journalists at The Guardian and The Washington Post faced similar decisions when they received documents from National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden and subsequently published selected portions of them as The NSA Files and NSA Secrets. The New York Times and ProPublica subsequently worked together to report on the documents.

In each case, the editors and reporters working on these stories have had to make difficult, important decisions about what information to publish. These aren’t novel calls, given many decades of correspondence from wars, tribunals or peace negotiations, but the sensitivity of the subject matter and global reach of published data create a context that can’t be ignored. While few journalists will come into possession of documents like the Snowden leaks over the course of their careers, the way that these stories were reported collaboratively syndicated and the data itself protected is going to be an important case study for generations to come.

Whither ethics in data?

For more the ethics in data journalism, it’s worth reading a series of extracts from a draft book chapter by Birmingham City University professor Paul Bradshaw, including:

Portions of this post were excerpted from a draft report on data-driven journalism, due to be published by the Tow Center in spring 2014.

 

Alexander Howard is a Tow Fellow working on the Tow Center’s Data Journalism Project at the Tow Center for Digital Journalism.  The Data Journalism Project is a project made possible by generous funding from both The Tow Foundation and the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation. The Data Journalism Project includes a wide range of academic research, teaching, public engagement and development of best practices in the field of data and computational journalism. Follow Alexander Howard on Twitter @digiphile. To learn more about the Tow Center Fellowship Program, please contact the Tow Center’s Research Director Taylor Owen: taylor.owen@columbia.edu.

 

Category: Past Events

10 Comments

mohamed mahmoud Sep 02, 2014
شركة نيل للتسويق الكتروني شركة نيل للتسويق الكتروني شركة نيل للتسويق الكتروني نقل اثاث شركة تنظيف مجالس بالرياض شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض شركة تنظيف بالرياض شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض مكافحة حشرات شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض شركة تنظيف بيارات بالرياض شركة تسليك مجارى بالرياض شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض شركة عزل اسطح بالرياض شركة عزل خزانات بالرياض رش مبيدات شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض شركة تسليك مجارى بالرياض شركة عزل خزانات بالرياض شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض مكافحة النمل الابيض بالمدينة المنورة شركة لتاجير السيارات بمصر غسيل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة شركة تنظيف شقق بالمدينة المنورة شركة تنظيف فلل بالمدينة المنورة شركة تنظيف المنازل بالمدينة المنورة مكافحة حشرات بالمدينة المنورة شركة عزل اسطح بالمدينة المنورة ليموزين الاقصر ليموزين مدينة نصر ليموزين مدينتي ليموزين الرحاب شركات تاجير السيارات بالاسكندرية ايجار سيارات كابورليه ايجار سيارات فى شرم الشيخ ايجار سيارات فى طنطا ايجار سيارات فى مدينة نصر تأجير سيارات لشركات البترول رقم تليفون ليموزين المطار اسعار ايجار السيارات في مصر شركات الليموزين فى مصر شركة سياحة فى مصر رحلات الى اسطنبول رحلات شهر العسل الى تركيا رحلات تركيا من مصر اسعار السياحة في تركيا رحلات سياحية الى تركيا رحلات الى تركيا عروض شركات السياحة شركات سياحة شركة انشاءات شركات عقارات مكتب هندسي معماري شركة معمارية شركات الاستشارات الهندسية شركات المقاولات فى مصر تصميمات فلل ديكورات شقق واجهات عمائر شركة ديكور تشطيبات شقق تنظيف موكيت بالمدينة المنورة عزل مائى بالدمام شركة عزل حرارى بالمدينة المنورة تنظيف خزانات بالدمام تنظيف بيارات بالدمام نقل عفش الدمام تخزين اثاث شركة تخزين عفش تنظيف بيارات بجدة دهانات فلل من الداخل شركة تنظيف بالهفوف شركة تنظيف بيارات بالدمام شركة تخزين أثاث بالظهران شركة تنظيف مساجد بمكة شركه كشف تسربات المياه بالقطيف شركة عزل أسطح بالمجمعة شركة عزل أسطح بالخبر شركة عزل اسطح بالظهران شركة تخزين أثاث بالخبر شركة تنظيف تكييف بمكة شركة نقل اثاث بالهفوف شركة تخزين اثاث بالهفوف شركة تنظيف بسيهات شركة تسليك مجاري بالخبر شركة تسليك مجارى بسيهات شركة تخزين أثاث بالدمام شركة تنظيف بيارات برأس التنورة شركة تنظيف فلل بالجبيل شركة تسليك مجارى بالجبيل شركة مكافحة حشرات ورش مبيدات بالأحساء شركة مكافحة حشرات ورش مبيدات بسيهات شركة تخزين اثاث بالجبيل شركة تنظيف برأس التنورة شركة تنظيف تكييف بالرياض شركة تنظيف بالخرج شركة تسليك مجارى بالهفوف شركة كشف تسرب المياه بالهفوف شركة تنظيف بالمجمعة شركة عزل خزانات بسيهات شركة نقل اثاث بالقاهرة
esyhrehfgxjhfgxj Aug 04, 2014
freujykuv;It p90x workout is nike mercurial reported oakley sunglasses outlet that timberland in rayban early longchamp 2012 borse louis vuitton the jimmy choo first jerseys public louboutin shoes occasion, cheap sunglasses Mr. lululemon canada Ma karen millen uk was polo ralph lauren also abercrombie grappling true religion with ray ban the birkin bag process hogan of jordan shoes foreign ralph lauren outlet online Secret cheap sunglasses year louboutin outlet two ralph lauren outlet mainstream tiffany and co microblogging, ralph lauren polo "Everyone air max pas cher regardless oakley sunglasses of gucci handbags cost," ralph lauren he michael kors outlet said, ralph lauren uk Tencent sac hermes microblogging longchamp handbags tens louis vuitton bags of burberry pas cher millions coach handbags of oakley outlet advertising ray ban investment, ferragamo outlet Sina true religion outlet Weibo karen millen tens ralph lauren outlet of burberry handbags millions burberry factory outlet on ray ban uk advertising nike outlet investment vans grappling. ralph lauren outlet online A michael kors quarter polo ralph lauren earnings sac michael kors report oakley sunglasses cheap that burberry came valentinos out burberry factory outlet last oakley outlet year, gucci shoes investors north face jackets put marc jacobs too louis vuitton much replica watches special burberry outlet online attention balance shoes to ray bans the sac lancel Tencent converse microblogging, prada outlet "see longchamp that salvatore ferragamo we michael kors are ray ban pas cher playing hogan outlet hard mulberry uk to sac longchamp pas cher see, nike air max if oakley vault bruising cheap oakley sunglasses Tencent raybans microblogging, louis vuitton handbags Sina sac longchamp will cheap sunglasses Manlianshixue. oakley sunglasses "The true religion outlet March louis vuitton uk 27, new balance 2014, oakley vault this jordan pas cher was lululemon outlet known oakley vault as nike free Ma montblanc Manlianshixue michael kors pas cher Sina coach factory Weibo coach outlet officially louis vuitton pas cher renamed burberry outlet as supra for sale "microblogging," supra shoes and air max in nike free run mid-April nike factory outlet in nike air max the hermes pas cher United ghd hair States cheap sunglasses officially montre homme listed ray ban sunglasses on true religion NASDAQ. polo shirts Effect jordan retro of sac louis vuitton this coach outlet decision tory burch outlet is bottega veneta that oakley outlet the nike free run user louis vuitton first polo outlet reaction rayban since rayban then louboutin filed coach outlet store microblogging michael kors handbags no ray ban sunglasses longer louboutin pas cher believe louis vuitton outlet that ferragamo shoes microblogging coach outlet store is mulberry a chi hair category, oakley sunglasses outlet but ugg boots exclusively celine handbags Sina toms shoes outlet name, ray ban outlet which oakley sunglasses gave soccer jerseys all ray-ban being oakley sunglasses cheap developed, burberry already oakley pas cher fading beats by dre microblogging oakley sunglasses beautiful abercrombie and fitch blow.In chaussure louboutin the nike air max final oakley sunglasses cheap analysis, michael kors the new balance shoes strategic true religion jeans decision nike factory to ralph lauren adjust polo ralph lauren outlet naturally gucci from air max the nike free run enterprise north face outlet level hogan sito ufficiale to oakley sunglasses outlet evaluate burberry handbags the abercrombie kids level michael kors outlet online of lancel Tencent, longchamp bags has burberry nothing oakley to michael kors outlet do air max right free run or timberland pas cher wrong. rolex watches Titanium nike free media coach factory outlet editors louis vuitton not reebok skyscape to hermes Tencent tiffanys microblogging oakley sunglasses cheap fate michael kors outlet online and toms outlet regret, juicy couture outlet market oakley vault and converse shoes customer ralph lauren needs burberry outlet online already mont blanc decided hermes birkin its louis vuitton bags fate. scarpe hogan Today, red bottom shoes micro-channel oakley vault strong jordan 11 momentum juicy couture of cheap oakley sunglasses development, tory burch handbags has tory burch occupied nike shoes the nike free pas cher most ray bans important christian louboutin shoes mobile hollister terminal coach factory outlet entrance, polo ralph lauren outlet while vans pas cher stepping nike store on hermes handbags drums coach purses 4G oakley sunglasses will oakley sunglasses cheap support montre femme micro true religion outlet depending abercrombie and on prada handbags the ugg boots host, longchamp outlet will reebok outlet be air max the tiffany's Tencent oakley outlet next polo ralph lauren outlet online bet.ray ban outlet michael kors handbags cheap oakley sunglasses toms shoes yoga pants air max polo ralph lauren nike air max hermes belt gucci belts mcm bags ray ban beats headphones burberry outlet insanity workout polo shirts ray ban herve leger coach bags mont blanc pens louboutin lancel pas cher polo outlet asics running hermes birkin bag ugg boots louboutin nike tn ray-ban cheap sunglasses oakley sunglasses outlet longchamp pas cher coach outlet store online oakley raybans nike free run pas cher nike air max air jordan tory burch shoes kate spade outlet nike air max air max nfl jerseys polo ralph lauren outlet online hollister uk louis vuitton ralph lauren polo prada shoes the north face chanel bags lululemon coach factory outlet louis vuitton handbags chanel handbags air jordan rayban new balance outlet gucci outlet ralph lauren outlet sac burberry ralph lauren pas cher cheap oakley sunglasses oakley outlet nike free louboutin reebok shoes christian louboutin outlet louis vuitton outlet online oakley sunglasses outlet kate spade cheap oakley sunglasses montre pas cher shyezujrsxujh
coach factory outlet Jul 28, 2014
coach factory outlet,kate spade outlet online,hollister clothing store,michael kors outlet online,coach factory,coach outlet,coach factory outlet,coach outlet store online,coach outlet online,coach outlet store online,coach handbags,coach factory outlet,coach factory,coach outlet store online,official coach factory outlet,hollister clothing,coach factory,coach outlet online,coach factory outlet online,coach factory,coach factory,coach outlet,coach factory outlet,coach factory outlet,kate spade outlet online,coach outlet,coach outlet store online,coach factory,coach factory outlet,michael kors outlet online,coach outlet store online,coach factory outlet,coach factory outlet online,coach factory outlet,coach outlet,coach factory outlet,coach outlet,cheap ray ban sunglasses,oakley sunglasses,oakley sunglasses,tory burch shoes,true religion outlet,timberland outlet,prada handbags,prada outlet,true religion jeans,celine handbags,fitflop fitflops,true religion jeans,fitflop uk,tory burch outlet,valentino,tiffany and co jewelery,timberland shoes,tory burch,true religion jeans outlet,true religion outlet,prada handbags,fitflops,prada outlet,timberland boots,tiffany jewelry,abercrombie and fitch,air jordan,celine outlet,toms shoes,true religion,fitflop shoes,supra shoes,isabel marant shoes,timberland,celine outlet,michael kors outlet online,ralph lauren,isabel marant, cheap jordans,marc jacobs,Polo ralph lauren,tiffany and co,coach factory outlet online,coach factory outlet,coach outlet online,coach outlet,coach outlet store online,coach factory outlet,coach outlet,coach factory outlet,coach factory,michael kors outlet,coach factory outlet,coach factory outlet online,coach outlet online,coach factory outlet online,official coach online factory sale,tory burch outlet online,kate spade outlet,michael kors outlet,michael kors outlet,michael kors outlet,michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet,sac portefeuille,michael kors outlet,coach outlet online,michael kors outlet online,michael kors outlet online,coach outlet store online,kate spade,michael kors,michael kors outlet online,michael kors outlet,louis vuitton handbags,louis vuitton outlet,louis vuitton outlet,louis vuitton outlet,louis vuitton,louis vuitton outlet,louis vuitton,kate spade online,abercrombie and fitch,abercrombie & fitch,abercrombie & fitch,fitflop uk,fitflops,tiffany jewelry,michael kors,ray ban sunglasses,oakley sunglasses cheap,cheap oakley sunglasses,oakley sunglasses outlet,kate spade outlet
polo outlet Jul 10, 2014
Handbags Outlet, http://www.superbagsmarket.com/ Louis Vuitton Outlet Hermes Bags Outlet Prada Outlet Online Chanel Outlet Gucci Outlet Burberry Outlet Online Celine Outlet Online Balenciaga Outlet Online Christian Bior Outlet Chloe Outlet Bvlgari Outlet Bally Outlet Online coach Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet MCM Backpack Outlet Fendi Outlet mulberry Outlet Online Marc Jacobs Outlet Online Miu Miu Outlet Ysl Outlet Tory Burch Outlet Givenchy Outlet Ferragamo Outlet Lancel Outlet Loewe Bags Outlet Tods Outlet Paul Smith Outlet D&G Bags Outlet Alexander Wang Outlet Bottega Veneta Outlet Life will always be confused, no one can really predict, the future, Hermes Outlet Online, Live in the world, Ralph Lauren UK, and so we were growing up, Sac Longchamp Pairs, in the confusion, Michael Kors Outlet Online, life of all things, the same is spent also confused, Beats By Dre Outlet, confused, Michael Kors Outlet, confused world, Ralph Polo Outlet, in this world, I am a leaf, Oakley Sunglaases Factory, accompanied by wind, North Face Outlet Online, leisurely, Super Bags Market, but spent 12 years in trouble, Canada Goose Outlet, me than to know their own future, Burberry Outlet, but do not know the survival dream, because I was so small, Polo Outlet Store, wind, Michael Kors Outlet, quietly floating, Coach Factory, I stood under a tree, Gucci Shoes Outlet, watching the falling leaves, MCM Outlet, know that fall, North Clearace Outlet, at the very bottom, I perhaps these leaves, Marc Jacobs On Sale, to know fall, Monster Beats Outlet, but still could not find a direction, Nike Jordan Shoes, in the confusion.
Ben Nov 20, 2013
You got one thing right, it's an ethical discussion, not a legal discussion.

Post a comment

We're trying to advance the conversation, and we trust that you will, too. We'd rather not moderate, but we will remove any comments that are blatantly inflammatory or inappropriate. Let it fly, but keep it clean. Thanks.