The Effects of Mass Surveillance on Journalism

October 10, 2013 by

Mass surveillance of the kind practiced by the NSA produces a chilling effect on journalism, because sources do not feel they can have a private conversation with a reporter. That’s the message of a group of scholars, journalists, and researchers from Columbia Journalism School and the MIT Center for Civic Media, in a public comment to the Review Group on Intelligence and Communication Technologies convened by President Obama.

The 15 page letter argues that mass surveillance is harmful to journalism and incompatible with existing law and policy. It goes on to document recent chilling effects, showing that real harm has already occurred.

“Put plainly, what the NSA is doing is incompatible with the existing law and policy protecting the confidentiality of journalist-­‐source communications. This is not merely an incompatibility in spirit, but a series of specific and serious discrepancies between the activities of the intelligence community and existing law, policy, and practice in the rest of the government. Further, the climate of secrecy around mass surveillance activities is itself actively harmful to journalism, as sources cannot know when they might be monitored, or how intercepted information might be used against them.”

The letter documents how NSA’s domestic phone and internet surveillance activities contradict recent Department of Justice policy. The DoJ released new guidelines regarding access to reporter-source communication records in July, after a review prompted by the secret seizure of records for 20 Associated Press phone lines. The new guidelines say that “the Department views the use of tools to seek evidence from or involving the news media as an extraordinary measure” and requires advance notification to journalists in most cases, to give them the opportunity to contest the matter. It also requires Attorney General approval for searches and seizures.

The NSA operates with far greater latitude. It preemptively collects and archives the records of all calls made to or by journalists, effectively bypassing both the notice and the authorization provisions of the DoJ policy. The NSA operates under “minimization” procedures designed to protect the confidentiality of Americans’ communications obtained by warrantless surveillance, but these rules contain an important exception: the NSA can report many different types of crimes to law enforcement authorities.

The letter argues that this double standard is intolerable: “there must be one set of rules, and those rules must protect journalist-­‐source communications.” The authors also reject the logic of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court when it asserts that collecting information on everyone is no different, from a privacy point of view, than collecting information on specific individuals.

“The surveillance of essentially everyone has effects far beyond the surveillance of journalists alone. … For a free press to function we must also protect the means of communicating with a journalist. At the present time, the NSA has made private electronic communication essentially impossible.”

This state of affairs has made sources nervous about talking to reporters. Journalists from news organizations including the Associated Press, the Washington Post, the New York Times, and the Center for Public Integrity have recently reported chilling effects. As quoted in a newly released report of the Committee To Protect Journalists, New York Times national security reporter Scott Shane describes the problem:

“There’s a gray zone between classified and unclassified information, and most sources were in that gray zone. Sources are now afraid to enter that gray zone. It’s having a deterrent effect. If we consider aggressive press coverage of government activities being at the core of American democracy, this tips the balance heavily in favor of the government.”

Mass surveillance is not merely a theoretical risk to a free press, but has real consequences that are already preventing journalists from doing their job.

The comment was prepared by a group of  journalists and scholars with experience in investigative journalism, online media, and data mining, including Tow Center Director Emily Bell, Toni Stabile Center for Investigative Journalism Director Sheila Coronel, Tow Center Fellow Jonathan Stray, and Professor Michael Schudson of Columbia Journalism School, and Ethan Zuckerman, Director of the MIT Center For Civic Media.

Category: Past Events, Research


huangxiaoxianhuangxiaoxian Jul 16, 2014
It only requires nike air max a burberry outlet online handful rolex watches of ferragamo outlet seconds cheap oakley sunglasses but nike air max will coach factory outlet make gucci managing your project north face outlet a lot less difficult. When you're prepared hogan to p90x workout commence tory burch outlet your juicy couture session hermes belt switch polo ralph lauren outlet on nike free the converse shoes answering true religion machine hogan (if you have nike air max one nike air max particular) vans pas cher and reduce the nike air max ring tone volume. Microphones can't rayban b excluded longchamp handbags from your sound bottega veneta system rental louboutin checklist. louis vuitton When vehicles rayban switched louboutin to oakley sunglasses cheap 12-volt herve leger batteries, the louis vuitton bags very oakley sunglasses same coach bags arrangement was louis vuitton applied, with nike air max tubes with 12-volt coach outlet store heaters. hollister When utilized chanel bags for toms shoes reside performances, oakley the michael kors outlet signal created ralph lauren pas cher by soccer jerseys the karen millen mixer ralph lauren uk will generally coach factory outlet be jimmy choo sent louboutin straight jerseys to an louis vuitton amplifier, louboutin unless nike air max that jordan retro certain oakley mixer is celine handbags "powered" or nike air max it ray ban sunglasses is montre femme becoming connected to powered speakers. ghd hair Other longchamps accessories longchamps that lululemon canada can be asics running employed reebok skyscape with ralph lauren outlet microphones are boom stands, mulberry pop filters, mounts, nike mercurial transformers, nike factory stand prada outlet arms valentinos and lululemon outlet wind ray ban sunglasses screens. nike uk It michael kors handbags is timberland attainable coach factory you montblanc will true religion outlet finish up nike air max paying true religion outlet much insanity workout more supra for sale for your marc jacobs installation chi hair then ray ban the actual stereo new balance shoes if you mcm bags are lancel not cautious.
Blackberry spy software Jul 07, 2014
Yeah Journalism has some reservation on surveillance especially the NSA doing on it's media and neighbor countries. Recently an American NSA agent caught in Berlin for spying on German authorities and how insane it is. Ain't ? I've posted about this news and read for more information here Blackberry spy software
coach factory outlet Jun 16, 2014
michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet coach outlet cheap oakley sunglasses oakley sunglasses outlet louis vuitton handbags coach factory outlet coach outlet store online coach factory michael kors outlet online coach outlet prada outlet air jordan true religion jeans coach factory outlet louis vuitton outlet coach factory outlet oakley sunglasses michael kors coach factory outlet prada handbags coach outlet louis vuitton handbags cheap oakley sunglasses cheap jordan true religion jeans outlet louis vuitton coach factory coach store online coach factory online michael kors outlet coach factory outlet prada handbags michael kors outlet coach outlet store online coach outlet valentino valentino shoes louis vuitton outlet coach outlet online coach factory outlet online isabel marant Shoes coach outlet store online timberland boots coach outlet oakley sunglasses coach outlet online true religion outlet coach outlet coach outlet store online coach factory coach factory outlet timberland shoes true religion outlet coach outlet store online coach outlet coach factory coach factory outlet true religion coach outlet store online true religion jeans coach factory louis vuitton coach factory outlet michael kors outlet coach factory outlet polo ralph lauren coach outlet store online tiffany and co coach factory outlet coach outlet online michael kors outlet online coach outlet online coach factory outlet online celine outlet cheap toms coach outlet celine handbags marc jacobs outlet michael kors purses coach outlet ralph lauren coach factory outlet toms shoes coach outlet online supra shoes coach outlet fitflop outlet tiffany jewelry tiffany and co coach factory michael kors outlet online coach outlet michael kors outlet store marc jacobs celine bags coach factory outlet coach handbags outlet timberland boots michael kors factory outlet fitflops coach factory outlet toms shoes louis vuitton handbags oakley sunglasses cheap prada factory
Paul - surveillance expert Oct 21, 2013
Isnt it a case sometimes though that the press need to be reigned in a little?

Post a comment

We're trying to advance the conversation, and we trust that you will, too. We'd rather not moderate, but we will remove any comments that are blatantly inflammatory or inappropriate. Let it fly, but keep it clean. Thanks.